Musical genius Lord Andrew Lloyd Weber was in the American Idol house last night. After a string of broadway-infused performances, here's how the final 6 are ranked by number of influential posts:

David Cook: 7128 **Influencer pick for Top 2 finalist.

Jason Castro: 6261 **Bottom 3 pick. The buzz on his song choice -- Cats' "Memory" -- was overwhelmingly negative.

David Archuleta: 5988 **Influencer pick for Top 2 finalist.

Brooke White: 5748 **Influencers' pick to go home. The start and stop performance put the bloggers over the edge and almost all agree it's time this songbird flew the coop.

Syesha Mercado: 5052 **Bottom 3 pick. The influencers talk about the "curse of the first" and many are buzzing about her leaving the show, despite liking her rendition of "One Rock & Roll Too Many" from the Starlight Express 2.

Carly Smithson: 4743 **Influencers loved the Jesus Christ Superstar pick and her Simon Loves Me (This Week) T-Shirt.